Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nathan Smith's avatar

Good article, but I would push back some on the idea that AI is a winner-take-all race between America and China.

That's not the case with technology in general. Ideas can spread across frontiers. You don't have to invent it in order to use it. The followers can be better off than the leader: they avoid the early mistakes and adopt mature technologies.

Military technologies are different, and presumably AI has military applications, although AI chatbots and military drones operating beyond line of sight are pretty different and may be a different space. But even military AI only seems like a winner-take-all race if one power gets ahead and then conquers the other by virtue of its its technologically enabled military superiority. Otherwise, there's time to catch up even if you "lose the race."

What exactly is the scenario where China "wins?" Do we keep using our American chatbots, but it's depressing to know that China's are better? Do we use Chinese chatbots, and get all the productivity gains, but must endure the shame of owing those gains to foreigners? Or does China charge us through the nose for their cutting-edge AI, or fill chatbot responses with Chinese propaganda? But then, wouldn't we just stop using them?

I'm all for adopting AI, but I'm not yet convinced that there's a meaningful "race" dynamic here. Or at least, it needs a lot more explanation to be credible, and whatever truth there is in it probably needs a better, more precise, less expansive description than "the AI race."

Charles Oltorf's avatar

AI is really the salvation of democracy, if used properly. The majority can guide our leaders in a vague, general direction, if given a sense of the relative costs vs. benefits of the choice. What the public cannot do is to construct a cost benefit ratio of their choices if left to their own devices. I hope that AI can be utilized to inform us of the true consequences of our choices so that we, the people, can make truly informed decisions.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?