14 Comments
User's avatar
Jonnymac's avatar

Tried to explain to my parents that no, they did not in fact pre-pay their Medicare in full, not even close, and they just don't believe me.

Ryan Teetsel's avatar

It’s understandable when that’s what politicians have been telling them all their lives :/

Just Some Guy's avatar

It's not in politicians’ interest to tell the most politically active segment of the population that they are putting an unsustainable burden upon the younger generations.

Somebody else has to do it. Someone needs to start Old People for Entitlement Reform.

Wait. Why are you looking at me like that?

Ryan Teetsel's avatar

It shouldn't have to be generational warfare. Seniors that care about their children and grandchildren should support commonsense, incremental entitlement reforms. It's the patriotic thing to do.

Just Some Guy's avatar

Of course that's true. That's how it has to be sold. By old people who care about their children and grandchildren to old people who care about their children and grandchildren. If they care about the country, that would also help.

I have no experience in the activism biz, but I think this might be my issue.

Anton Frattaroli's avatar

This is an argument for higher insurance prices. If you reduce the dollars coming in from Medicare (including Part B hospital outpatient and physician payments) it doesn’t lower fixed facility costs anywhere near as much as it lowers provider revenue. That revenue has to be made up somewhere else: commercial insurance premiums and higher deductibles. And taxes aren’t going to go down either.

Ryan Teetsel's avatar

I would respectfully push back here. Means-testing doesn’t change what Medicare pays hospitals. It simply changes how the bill is divided between seniors and taxpayers. Holding Medicare’s spending constant, I think wealthy seniors should pay more and taxpayers should pay less.

Anton Frattaroli's avatar

Why would wealthy seniors stay in a voluntary program after you remove the incentive for them to participate? And they’re usually healthier, so when they opt out Medicare’s left with a sicker risk pool and less total revenue

Ryan Teetsel's avatar

Even unsubsidized, Medicare offers standalone value as a guaranteed-issue plan with near-universal provider access (at least for Traditional, which wealthy beneficiaries tend to prefer). To your earlier point, Medicare also benefits from administered pricing, enabling it to offer lower premiums than commercial insurance can.

Mark's avatar

IRMA is a form of means testing that increases Medicare Part B and D based on income.

Ryan Teetsel's avatar

Indeed, but shouldn’t it go further? Does a billionaire really need a 15% subsidy for Parts B and D, on top of getting Part A for $0?

Mark's avatar

Yes, IRMA should have higher income brackets so it phases out all subsidies for Billionaires and keeps the system progressive.

forumposter123@protonmail.com's avatar

No, people who save for retirement should be punished. Cut benefits equally and poor people can just die a little sooner

Roger Eybel's avatar

Isn't a right or a privilege? Is it intended to prevent or treat after you have a health issue?